Padma awards: Call to merge three tiers and give Opposition a say in selection
An analysis argues that India's civilian honours have drifted from merit and that eight structural changes are needed to restore their credibility, three decades after the Supreme Court demanded norms.

A fresh case for overhauling the Bharat Ratna and Padma awards argues that India's highest civilian honours need structural reform, not periodic tinkering. The analysis, published by The Pioneer, proposes eight changes: a single merged Padma award, tighter nomination limits, pre-vetting by intelligence and tax authorities, and an Opposition role in selection. It also seeks transparency on every name considered and a clear mechanism for withdrawing honours.
The argument rests on a constitutional history. The awards were suspended twice, from 1977 to 1980 and from 1992 to 1995, after their legitimacy was challenged in court. They resumed only after the Supreme Court upheld their validity in Balaji Raghavan v. Union of India (1995) and asked for norms to keep selection merit-based. The analysis holds that this expectation remains unmet three decades later.
On design, the piece says that sorting roughly 130 awardees a year into Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Shri in a country of more than 1.4 billion lowers the standing of the Padma Shri. It proposes one merged Padma award. It also wants an end to "upgrades", where earlier awardees are decorated again. Under its model a Padma honour would be conferred once in a lifetime, and only the Bharat Ratna would remain open to existing Padma recipients.
The sharpest proposals target the process. The analysis would let an individual recommend only one name, while ministries, departments and constitutional authorities could send more through their secretariats. It cites reports that during the UPA years the AICC treasurer forwarded an excessive number of names, which burdened scrutiny and fed suspicion of fund-raising. Every nominee would be cleared by intelligence and tax authorities before reaching the Awards Committee, so members would examine a short, pre-cleared list.
The piece also targets who controls selection. The Prime Minister currently constitutes the Awards Committee, which the Cabinet Secretary heads. The analysis would have the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition choose its members by consensus, including an Opposition nominee. A higher Selection Committee chaired by the Vice-President would include the Central Vigilance Commissioner, with the Cabinet Secretary as secretary. The Bharat Ratna would need the agreement of both the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, a safeguard against political use of the country's top honour.
Two further proposals concern eligibility and openness. The piece would reserve the honours for resident Indians, noting that the Pravasi Bharatiya Samman and the Gandhi Peace Prize already serve overseas and international recipients. It points out that the 2026 list again included six foreign nationals or overseas Indians. It would also have the Home Ministry's website publish the full process after the Republic Day announcement: every name considered, who recommended it, and when the nomination reached the recommending authority and the Ministry. The analysis lists an eighth change as well, concerning Nobel laureates and medal winners.
The analysis is an argument for reform, not an official proposal, and none of its changes has been adopted. It nonetheless links a long-running credibility problem to a specific constitutional benchmark, the Supreme Court's 1995 call for merit-based norms, and offers a concrete test of whether the government and Parliament will act on it. Read the original analysis at The Pioneer.