Kurian panel member says Tamil Nadu dissolved Union-State committee without notice
K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty says the state gave him and Justice Kurian Joseph no warning, and that the work has been handed to a body ill-suited to take it on.

A member of Tamil Nadu's committee on Union-State relations has said neither he nor the panel's chairman, former Supreme Court judge Justice Kurian Joseph, received any advance warning before the state government dissolved the body. Retired IAS officer K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty made the claim in an interview with The Hindu's 360 YouTube channel, in which he also said the government had earlier cleared the panel to carry on its work.
According to Shetty's account, the trouble began in early May, when fellow member M. Naganathan resigned. The panel sought clarity from the government on whether it should continue, and Shetty asked the Chief Secretary to hold off on naming a replacement if it did. About a week later, he says, a senior official informed him that the government had agreed the panel could proceed without a new member. Other committees set up under the previous administration were asked to wind up, but his panel was not. Then, he says, it was dissolved without a prior conversation.
The government's order described the Kurian committee as a non-statutory body, and its remaining mandate has been transferred to the State Law Commission. Shetty disputes the logic. In his view, the Law Commission is also an executive body, constituted through government orders since 1994, and so enjoys no firmer legal footing than the panel it replaced. He placed the committee alongside the Punchhi and Sarkaria Commissions, which examined Centre-state relations through executive appointment as well.
The substance of the handover is where Shetty's objections carry the most weight. He argues that the State Law Commission has not examined Union-State ties in more than three decades, and that it already has seven or eight references before it. He estimates that the subject alone would take two years, which is longer than the Commission's usual three-year term. He also notes that a report has rarely, if ever, been split so that Part One and Part Two are written by different bodies.
The content of the unfinished work is a further complication. Part One dealt mainly with legal and constitutional questions. Part Two, Shetty says, moved into policy territory, including climate change, local governance, the arts, history, science, culture and transport, areas he argues sit outside a law commission's remit. Had the panel continued, he says, it would have submitted its final report by May 31.
The government has not, in the material available, publicly answered the specific procedural points Shetty raised. The episode nonetheless exposes a recurring tension in Indian federal policymaking: committees that shape Centre-state debates often depend on executive goodwill, and their continuity can change with a new administration. For a state seeking a considered view on Union-State relations, the question is less about who writes the report than whether the body writing it has the time, mandate and expertise to do the job.
Full interview: The Hindu, Tamil Nadu government gave no advance notice on Justice Kurian panel's dissolution