Musk accuses 'oligarchs' over Starlink; India's real test is who holds the switch
A public spat between Elon Musk and New Delhi has obscured the harder question of who controls satellite internet in India once it launches.

Elon Musk used X on October 7 to accuse unnamed "oligarchs" of blocking Starlink's entry into India, calling it a "crime against the people of India". The government rejected the charge as "baseless and misconceived". It said Starlink, Reliance Jio's Jio Satcom and the Bharti-backed Eutelsat OneWeb hold licences and sit at broadly the same stage: each awaits security clearance before spectrum is assigned.
An opinion piece in Scroll argues that the row misses the central issue. Starlink's arrival is not in serious doubt. What matters is the terms of entry, and who can shut the service off when the stakes are highest.
The case for speed rests on the connectivity gap. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India counted nearly 1.09 billion internet subscriptions at the end of March, but the average hides a wide divide. Cities have about 127 subscriptions per 100 people, against roughly 48 in rural India. The Internet and Mobile Association of India estimates that about 38% of Indians, close to 58 crore people, are not active users. Many live where cables and towers are hard to build: mountain villages, forested districts, the North East and the island territories.
The Ukraine war shows the other side. Starlink became central to Ukrainian battlefield communications in 2022. The Financial Times reported that October that Ukrainian units lost service as they advanced into recaptured territory. Musk declined a request to enable coverage near Crimea for a naval drone operation, saying he did not want SpaceX to be "complicit in a major act of war". In March 2025 he said Ukraine's front line would collapse if he switched the service off. The piece's point is that a private citizen in another country made a decision with consequences for a sovereign state at war.
India has already seen misuse. In December 2024, security forces recovered Starlink equipment from a militant camp in Manipur, and police in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands found that drug smugglers had used the service to reach Indian waters. Musk's reply was that Starlink beams are turned off over India. The author calls that both reassuring and revealing: whether the service works over Indian territory is, in the end, the company's call.
The Department of Telecommunications' 2025 security conditions try to move that authority to New Delhi. Operators must route Indian traffic through gateways in India and keep user data in the country. They must permit lawful interception and be able to restrict service in specific areas during hostilities. They must also manufacture at least 20% of their ground equipment in India within five years. The op-ed says these rules must bind every operator, foreign or Indian, and must be enforced in practice, not just on paper.
The article also concedes that Musk's complaint deserves a hearing on one point. "Sovereign" must not become a euphemism for "concentrated". If control over satellite internet passes from one foreign billionaire to two or three domestic conglomerates, citizens gain little. The test for regulators is whether the switch sits with the state and the rules, not with any single company.
Read the original opinion piece: India should welcome Musk's Starlink, but ensure that it holds the switch (Scroll.in).