Rubio calls "UN experts" an oxymoron, declines to judge India protest crackdown claims
The US Secretary of State stayed out of India's domestic row while mocking the UN experts whose allegations New Delhi has rejected at the General Assembly.

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Wednesday brushed aside a question about UN criticism of India's handling of protests, joking that "UN experts" may be an oxymoron and saying Washington will not take sides in India's domestic politics. Asked about demonstrations by opposition parties and students, and about UN experts' allegations of a crackdown, he called it a political matter for Indian citizens to settle.
"I am not going to get involved in their politics. This is a democracy," Rubio said. He added that the US would not comment on internal political matters, which he described as "for the Indian people to decide and navigate." He neither endorsed nor disputed the specific allegations.
Rubio also drew a line between kinds of unrest. Peaceful protest and open political disagreement, he said, belong to democratic life, while riots involving vandalism, arson and destruction of property are a different matter. He pointed to Cuba as the contrast, where opposition voices risk prison, oppression or exile.
His remarks landed a day after India rebutted the UN experts at the General Assembly. Diplomat Barkha Tamrakar said India's constitutional safeguards, including Article 21, protect human rights and due process. She rejected what she called attempts to turn unverified allegations, incomplete statistics, or a report with no India country observation into a negative portrait of the country. Human rights, she said, should not become a tool of political pressure or selective targeting.
The experts at the centre of the dispute had alleged that Indian authorities were restricting peaceful assembly and carrying out enforced disappearances. India's side, as relayed by ANI, also argued that UN Human Rights Chief Volker Türk took a milder tone on police action against violent protests in France and elsewhere in Europe, and even called some protesters "vandals." That comparison reflects India's framing, not an independent finding.
The context matters for reading Rubio's quip. UN special experts are independent figures appointed under the Human Rights Council's special procedures. They do not speak for the Secretary-General or the organisation as a whole, and governments often contest their findings. Rubio's line gives New Delhi rhetorical cover in a dispute over credibility and process, but it stops short of a formal US position on the protests. The substance of the allegations remains unresolved.